Sun Pharmaceutical Q4FY12: Strong performance, but may not sustain
Strong Performance, But May Not Sustain
Sun Pharmaceutical Industries (SPL) reported stellar earnings for Q4FY12 and FY12, but Nirmal Bang believe they may not sustain going forward owing to the following reasons: a) Increase in tax rate in FY13 due to implementation of MAT for its partnership firm in Sikkim, b) Lower margins following a rise in R&D expenditure, c) Weak domestic formulations sales in H1FY13 due to pre-booked revenue in Q4FY12,and d) Lower revenue growth of Taro, as FY12 revenue was largely led by hike in product prices. At the current levels, Nirmal bang believe the stock is fairly valued and so they retain their Hold rating on it with a TP of Rs596, valuing it at 21x FY14E EPS of Rs28.3.
Q4FY12 results above expectations:
SPL’s Q4FY12 revenue at Rs23.4bn (up 60% YoY, 9% QoQ) and PAT of Rs8.2bn were above Nirmal bang/consensus estimates. Revenue growth was strong across geographies led by the US (up 83% YoY, 66% YoY in US dollar terms and flat QoQ – driven by Taro and anticancer drug-Lipodox sales), India (up 49% YoY; 21% YoY excluding pre-booked sales of Rs1.8bn) and ROW formulations (up 48% YoY, 31% YoY in US dollar terms and 15% QoQ). Margins stood at 41%, also above our/consensus estimates of 40%/39%, respectively, aided by robust margins of Taro and pre-booked domestic revenue. Tax rate at 16% was higher than normal, but was negated by higher other income (up 63%YoY due to maturing of investments), thereby leading to PAT growth of 85% YoY and 23% QoQ.
Taro’s performance beats expectations once again:
Taro once again exceeded expectations with revenue, EBITDA margin and PAT of USD145mn, 46% and USD47mn, respectively, all above Nirmal Bang/consensus estimates. However, a large portion of this was driven by product price hikes in the US, which, Nirmal Bang believe, is not sustainable. Also, with a thin US pipeline (only 16 ANDAs pending regulatory approval), Nirmal Bang believe SPL may struggle to sustain its FY12 performance.
Strong guidance, partially driven by favourable currency movement: SPL’s FY13 guidance of 18-20% revenue growth assumes an average rupee-dollar rate of Rs51 versus Rs47.9 in FY12, implying 6.5% growth due to favourable currency movement and another 12-13% growth in the base business. This indicates that maintaining growth on a high base may be difficult; barring Prandin, SPL’s own US generic pipeline looks quite ordinary to us.
Nirmal Bang roll over valuation to FY14E earnings; retain Hold rating on stock: Nirmal Bang roll over valuation to FY14E earnings and value SPL at 21xFY14E EPS of Rs28.3 to arrive at a target price of Rs596. They retain their Hold rating on the stock.
Click here to read the full report
Founded in 1986 by Nirmal Bang, the Nirmal Bangis recognized as one of the largest retail broking houses in India, providing an array of financial products and services. Their retail and institutional clients have access to products such as equities, derivatives, commodities, currency derivatives, mutual funds, IPOs, insurance, depository services and PMS. The Group is headed by Mr. Dilip Bang and Mr. Kishore Bang.
For more information please write in to firstname.lastname@example.org
Disclaimer: The author has taken due care and caution to compile and analyse the data. The opinions expressed above are only the views of the author, and not a recommendation to buy or sell. Neither the author nor IndiaNotes.com accept any liability whatsoever arising from the use of any of the above contents.
- Sun Pharma: PAT & profitability down in Q3, accumulate
- Q3FY15 Preview: Accumulate Ranbaxy and Sun Pharmaceuticals
- Sun Pharma Q3 Preview: Taro revenue to lead growth in US business, buy
- Sun Pharma Q2FY15: Sales in line, EBITDA disappoints
- Sun Pharma Q2FY15: Buy on dips to 840-873
Have a question?
Also On IndiaNotes.Com
- Colgate-Palmolive: Buy for an upside potential of 16%
- Stock tip: Buy McLeod Russel; targets Rs260/268