Indian Oil Corp Q1FY13: Earnings hit by fall in crude, INR
Indian Oil’s (IOCL) Q1FY13 loss of Rs224bn was worse than Edelweiss' estimate of loss of Rs79bn. GRMs at USD(4.8)/bbl was lower than their USD1.0/bbl estimate due to crude inventory losses of USD(7.5)/bbl as crude fell ~USD25/bbl QoQ. Marketing EBITDA was also lower than estimates as there was no under‐recovery compensation by the Govt in the quarter. Upstream companies shared 31.5% in Q1FY13, leading to IOCL posting a net under‐recovery of Rs175bn. Edelweiss estimates OMCs to bear 4% of gross under‐recovery in FY13/14. Edelweiss maintain their fair value of Rs333. Current market price implies zero value to marketing. Maintain ‘BUY’.
GRMs hit by inventory losses; diesel grows 8% YoY
Refining throughput at 13.6 mmt (101% utilization) was lower than the estimated 14.2 mmt due to maintenance shutdown. GRMs of USD(4.8)/bbl was much lower than Edelweiss' estimate of USD1.0/bbl as there was a crude inventory loss of Rs40.6bn, i.e. USD(7.5)/bbl. Thus, refining EBITDA loss at Rs32.3bn was lower than our Rs(1.0)bn estimate. Led by fuel pricing distortion, diesel sales continue to grow 8% YoY while the impact of petrol hikes clearly reflects in nil volume growth. Also, while LPG grew 6% YoY, SKO fell 12%. Forex loss of Rs31.8bn on crude and payables also impacted the refining EBITDA.
No Govt compensation in Q1; debt rises Rs155bn QoQ
IOCL’s Rs255bn gross under‐recovery (60% from diesel) was partly compensated by upstream to the extent of Rs80bn (31.5%). With no Govt sanctions in the quarter, IOC’s net under‐recovery was Rs175bn (68.5%). In addition, ~Rs91bn of pending Govt payments for FY12 led to a sharp increase in debt from Rs754bn to Rs909bn QoQ. Thus, interest expense was up 78% YoY. Marketing EBITDA loss was Rs180bn.
Outlook and valuations: Maintain SOTP of Rs333; ‘BUY’
Edelweiss retains their refining margin estimate of USD5.0/bbl for FY13 and FY14. They estimate FY13E EPS at Rs23.9 and FY14E EPS at Rs29.8 broadly in line with earlier estimates. Edelweiss also assumes IOCL to bear ~4% of gross under‐recoveries for FY13/14. Ergo, they maintain their fair value of Rs333. Current price implies zero value to the marketing business. Key trigger for the stock remains a hike in diesel prices. Maintain ‘BUY’.
Click here to read the full report
Edelweiss is one of the leading financial services company based in Mumbai, India. Its current businesses include investment banking, securities broking and investment management. They provide a wide range of services to corporations, institutional investors and high net-worth individuals.
For more information please write in to firstname.lastname@example.org
Disclaimer: The author has taken due care and caution to compile and analyse the data. The opinions expressed above are only the views of the author, and not a recommendation to buy or sell. Neither the author nor IndiaNotes.com accept any liability whatsoever arising from the use of any of the above contents.
Have a question?
- Buy Indian Oil Corporation for a target of Rs405
- Indian Oil Q4FY14: Results above estimates led by forex gains; buy
- Indian Oil Corp: Attractive valuations, buy
- IOCL's Disinvestment & How You Can Benefit From It?
- Sell Indian Oil (IOC) 180 put at 1.10
Also On IndiaNotes.Com
- Q2CY14 Result: Hexaware Technologies revenues disappoint; maintain neutral
- KPIT Tech Q1FY15: Earnings troughed, improving operating metrics; Buy